✍️ Part I. Simplistic Thinking Isn’t Leadership
Trump’s quick fixes expose the danger of simplistic politics
Simplistic thinking is everywhere these days. It shows up in comment threads, talk radio rants, and school board meetings. But lately, it’s also climbed into the highest levels of government — in the Trump administration.
Here’s the problem: Real-world issues are rarely simple.
Public policy. Education. Public health. Energy. Criminal justice. The economy. Climate change. Every one of those areas is layered with history, science, law, competing interests, and tough trade-offs.
But simplistic thinking skips all that.
It says, “We just need to do X.” Or worse, “I alone can fix it.” No research. No listening to experts or affected communities. Just a blind swing with a hammer.
That’s what we’re seeing right now. With a single stroke of a pen, Trump has ordered prosecutors to criminally pursue flag burning — despite clear Supreme Court rulings that protect it as free speech.
He has threatened cities with federal troops if they don’t “call him.” He has ordered states to strip so-called “gender ideology” from sex-ed classes or lose funding. And his agencies are deleting thousands of government web pages and datasets that deal with science, health, and the environment.
Each of these moves sounds decisive. Each comes with a slogan. But none respects the complexity of constitutional law, local authority, or evidence-based policymaking.
Imagine someone walking into a power plant or a hospital operating room, grabbing the nearest lever, and saying, “I’ve got this.”
That’s what it looks like when leaders enter public office with no curiosity, no respect for expertise, and no interest in the careful work that democracy requires.
It’s not leadership. It’s recklessness.
Without learning, planning, consultation, and evaluation, luck is the best outcome you can hope for. The worst is catastrophe.
We don’t need leaders who pretend everything’s easy. We need leaders—and citizens—who are willing to dig in, ask hard questions, listen carefully, and make decisions that reflect reality, not slogans.
Because complex systems don’t fix themselves with a flip of a switch.
Follow up in Part 2: Respecting facts, complexity, and democracy is the way forward.
Share
If my commentary resonates with you, please share it with friends.
Subscribe
Get new posts from Plainly, Garbl delivered to your inbox.